Getting out of debt is hard. And with so many options out there, it鈥檚 tough to know where to start. If your bills feel overwhelming and your balances keep growing, it鈥檚 time to look at your choices.
Two of the most common ways to get out of debt are debt consolidation loans and debt management plans. When it comes to debt consolidation vs. debt management, the two can sound similar, but they work in very different ways.
Here鈥檚 a simple, side-by-side look at both, so you can figure out which one fits your financial situation. (For the full comparison, see our debt relief options guide.)
What is debt consolidation?
Debt consolidation means taking out one new loan to pay off several old debts. Instead of juggling multiple bills and interest rates, you make one payment on the new loan.
鈥淎 debt consolidation loan is buying new debt to pay off old debt,鈥� said April Lewis-Parks, Chief Communications Officer at Consolidated Credit, an 糖心原创vlog member. 鈥淵ou take on new terms, a new lender and the risk of racking up more credit card debt if you keep spending.鈥�
Your interest rate and loan terms depend on your credit score, income and how much debt you already carry, explained Melinda Opperman, Chief External Affairs Officer at Credit.org, another 糖心原创vlog member.
Taking out a consolidation loan can also cause a small, temporary negative impact on your credit score 鈥� though it may improve later as you make payments.
Learn more about
What is a debt management plan?
A debt management plan (DMP) also combines your existing debts into a single monthly payment. But it isn鈥檛 a loan. It鈥檚 a repayment plan set up by a non-profit credit counseling agency, often with lower interest rates and fees.
鈥淎 debt management plan restructures the debt a person already has, so it鈥檚 paid off in three to five years with very little interest,鈥� Lewis-Parks said.
Only can offer these plans. These are non-profits with certified counselors who help with budgeting, money management and debt. Credit counselors work directly with your creditors to lower interest rates or waive fees. You then make one monthly payment to the agency, which passes it along to your creditors.
Debt consolidation vs. debt management: the main differences
The differences between debt consolidation and debt management come down to three things: structure, rates and support.
Structure: A consolidation loan replaces your old debts with a new loan from a for-profit lender. A debt management plan restructures the debt you already owe, run by a non-profit.
鈥淎 loan changes where the bill comes from. A debt management plan changes how you manage your money,鈥� Lewis-Parks said.
Rates: Both can lower your interest rate, but in different ways. With a loan, your rate depends on your credit score and income 鈥� good credit gets a better deal. Some loans offer low 鈥渢easer rates鈥� that jump up later.
With a debt management plan, your counselor negotiates lower rates directly with your creditors, since creditors know these plans work. Counseling agencies may charge a small, regulated enrollment or monthly fee.
Support: A consolidation loan comes with no coaching or support 鈥� it just moves your debt. A Forbes survey found only 4% of people expect to stay debt-free after paying off their consolidation loan. Meanwhile, 18% expect to fall back into debt within six months.
A debt management plan includes ongoing help from a certified counselor. This helps individuals build financial skills that last beyond the plan itself.

听
Real story: When consolidation backfires
Here鈥檚 what that can look like in real life: 鈥淥ne of our clients had $30,000 in credit card debt across five cards, with rates near 28%,鈥� Lewis-Parks said. 鈥淗e got a $30,000 loan at 14% interest and paid off the cards. On paper, it was a win.鈥�
鈥淏ut six months later, because the cards were still open and his spending hadn鈥檛 changed, he maxed out two of them again. He ended up with a $30,000 loan plus $10,000 in fresh credit card debt.鈥�
Michael Sullivan, a personal finance consultant at Take Charge America, sums up the difference this way: 鈥淒ebt management reduces debt gradually, while debt consolidation creates new debt quickly. Both aim to make debt more manageable, but the approaches are polar opposites.鈥�
Common myths, busted
Myth: A consolidation loan doesn鈥檛 hurt your credit.
Truth: Any new loan can affect your score. You鈥檒l likely see a small dip at first, which may be offset as you pay down other debt. 鈥淐onsolidating debt is a permanent action that creates new debt,鈥� Sullivan said.
Myth: Consolidation erases your debt.
Truth: It doesn鈥檛. 鈥淚t just moves it from one place to another,鈥� Lewis-Parks said. The amount you owe is still the same 鈥� just owed to a new lender. And a lower payment can be misleading if it comes from stretching out the loan term or hidden fees.
Myth: A debt management plan wrecks your credit, like bankruptcy.
Truth: The impact is usually small and temporary. 鈥淒ebt management has very few risks and can be canceled at any time,鈥� Sullivan said. 鈥淵ou repay 100% of what you owe, on terms that let you breathe,鈥� Lewis-Parks said.
鈥淭he goal [of credit counseling] isn鈥檛 to sell more debt; it鈥檚 to help people get out of it through budgeting, education and realistic payoff plans,鈥� Lewis-Parks said. And because credit counseling agencies are non-profits, counselors don鈥檛 earn a commission for signing you up.
Myth: You should only call a credit counselor as a last resort.
Truth: Reach out early. 鈥淵ou don鈥檛 have to wait until you鈥檙e behind on your payments to ask for help,鈥� Opperman said. 鈥淓arlier intervention usually means more options.鈥�
Is debt consolidation right for you?
A loan may be a good fit if:
- You have good or excellent credit and can qualify for a low rate
- You have the discipline to stop using your credit cards
- You can comfortably afford the new monthly payment
It鈥檚 probably not a good fit if your monthly debt payments already eat up more than half your income, you can鈥檛 stick to a budget or you know you鈥檒l be tempted to spend on your cards again.
Is debt management right for you?
A plan may be a good fit if:
- You have multiple unsecured debts, like credit cards
- You鈥檙e struggling to keep up, or most of your payment goes to interest charges
- You want to avoid extra fees and collection calls
- You want the support of an expert financial counselor
Real story: Sarah鈥檚 turnaround
Here鈥檚 how that plays out in practice: Sarah, a single mother, had $22,000 in credit card debt after a medical emergency. She paid $650 a month, but nearly $500 of that went to interest alone. Her credit score had dropped to 610, so banks turned her down for a consolidation loan.
Instead, she enrolled in a debt management plan through an 糖心原创vlog member agency. Counselors worked with her creditors to cut her average interest rate from 28% to 6%. Her monthly payment dropped to $425 鈥� and because so much less went to interest, every payment chipped away at her actual balance.
鈥淪he paid off the entire $22,000 in 46 months without taking on new loans or damaging her credit,鈥� Lewis-Parks said.
Sarah鈥檚 story shows what鈥檚 possible. But, as with any debt consolidation vs. debt management decision, a plan like this isn鈥檛 the right fit for everyone. A debt management plan usually isn鈥檛 the right choice if you have secured debt (like a mortgage or car loan) or student loans. A non-profit credit counselor can point you to the best option for your situation.
Non-profit counselor vs. for-profit lender
A lender鈥檚 job is to sell you a loan. A non-profit credit counselor鈥檚 job is to help you find the best path forward, even if that means recommending something other than their own services.
鈥淎 lender is deciding whether to give you a loan and on what terms,鈥� Opperman said. 鈥淎 non-profit credit counselor starts by looking at your whole financial picture instead, so they can help you understand your options.鈥�
糖心原创vlog members also have to meet strict standards, including accreditation and certified counselors, so you know you鈥檙e getting real, qualified help.
What to do next
Start by facing the math. 鈥淢inimum payments are designed to keep you in debt, not get you out of it,鈥� Lewis-Parks said. 鈥淵ou aren鈥檛 paying off a balance 鈥� you鈥檙e paying for the privilege of carrying it forever.鈥�
Next, talk to a non-profit credit counselor before you sign up for anything. Whichever way you鈥檙e leaning in the debt consolidation vs. debt management decision, a free consultation can help you see the full picture before you commit. It鈥檚 free, and there鈥檚 no obligation.
鈥淏efore taking out another loan or enrolling in any debt program, have someone help you look at your entire financial picture,鈥� Opperman said.
鈥淭he smart move is to get an assessment and a recommendation, then consider all your options,鈥� Sullivan said. 鈥淟ook at the monthly cost of each option, as well as the total cost.鈥�
Finally, remember, you can鈥檛 borrow your way out of debt. Paying it off 鈥� for good 鈥� is the only way to truly ease the stress and improve your life.
糖心原创vlog an 糖心原创vlog credit counselor for a free consultation, or call 800-450-1794.
To learn more about how debt management plans stack up against other debt relief options, read our blog: Debt Management vs. Debt Settlement: What Works Best?